The Disappointment of Roger Goodell

Football has problems.


Roger Goodell, his black bow-tie snug to his neck, beamed. His tailored tuxedo jacket broke at his shoulders, which bounced in-sync with his amusement. Former Dallas Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach, presenting at the National Football Foundation’s Annual Awards Dinner on December 8, had just quipped: “I had a chance to sit next to the commissioner of football, Pete Rozelle tonight…Oh, excuse me, Roger Goodell. I apologize. I had six concussions in the NFL.”

Unease lofted from the more than 1,500 people seated inside the Waldorf-Astoria’s Grand Ballroom. Goodell, undaunted, broadened his smile and intensified his laughter. Tasteless, smug arrogance from the self-professed protector of the shield, a boardroom champion elected to his post by win-at-all-costs NFL owners.


Photo courtesy of ESPN

Seated at a table less than thirty-yards from Goodell, I slugged half my glass of red table wine, swallowed, and pursed my staining-purple lips. The cocktail-party humor had hit home, and the offensive reaction from football’s vile prophet had struck a nerve.

I scanned the dais, moving through sixteen hall of fame faces, national champions, and Heisman Trophy winners. Football legends seated at the head table; men who limp and cringe with simple steps. Academic All-Americans flanked their sides, as did heroes from our nation’s service academies, the evening’s Distinguished American Award winners. Condoleezza Rice sat waiting her turn to speak as the recipient of the NFF’s Gold Medal award. My eyes swept past these faces and zeroed in on my mother. As the crowd’s laughter faded, hers was the reaction I sought.

Mom sat on the dais in honor of her late husband, Hall of Fame inductee Rob Lytle. Dad had starred at the University of Michigan from 1974-1976, leaving as the school’s all-time leader in rushing yards and finishing third in voting for the Heisman Trophy in 1976. Legendary Wolverines Coach Bo Schembechler called him the “toughest player” he ever coached. His teammates said he was the most humble teammate they ever had. Following Michigan, Dad played for the Denver Broncos, becoming the first player to score a touchdown in the Rose Bowl and the Super Bowl. Dad retired in 1984 after seven seasons and a smorgasbord of injuries, including—in his words—double digit concussions. On November 20, 2010, Dad suffered a massive heart attack and died. He was 56-years old.

Mom and Dad began dating in high school and Mom, perhaps more than anyone on the Waldorf’s stage, had earned her seat. She earned it by caring for—and carrying—Dad in life before, during, and after his career. She had enjoyed the good days, when Dad racked up yards for Michigan’s steamrolling rushing attacks in the mid-seventies. With his sandy blonde hair and easy smile, Dad was everybody’s All-American.

RL 41 v2

Rob Lytle; Photo Courtesy Lytle Family

Mom earned her seat in the bad days, too, the tear-filled Sundays she spent tucked into a corner seat at the mile high point of Denver’s Mile High Stadium. “Catch the ball…Lytle, you bum…Run harder!” The fans’ disappointment accelerated with each season. Mom hid where she could to avoid the insults. What fans never saw, though, was how Dad was an invalid during the week who transformed into a warrior on Sundays by fixing a cocktail of cortisone, painkillers, adrenaline, and his obsession to play football. Or how, as the toll of injuries overwhelmed his skills, Dad would spend his off days alone in dark rooms, paralyzed emotionally by his fading football career. Mom would drag him from the house and force him to see a life with more than football.

Mom earned her spot on the hall of fame dais in the dark days. These were the years after Dad retired when he summoned all his ex-athlete bravado to charm his way through the day only to sit on his living room couch crying into the night. Mom wrapped her arms around him, held his head, and let him weep over losing the game that had been his life’s driving purpose while Barbara Streisand howled from an antique record player over the memories of lost days in the sun. Dad thought himself nothing without football. Mom showed him he could be more.

And Mom earned her place in Dad’s final days, when the toll of nearly thirty operations, double-digit concussions, and thousands of on-field collisions squeezed the last beats from his heart. When vertigo stranded Dad lost and confused at the grocery store he had been visiting since childhood, Mom rescued him. She helped him schedule meetings, monitor appointments, and lift his spirit. Doctors would posthumously diagnose Dad with moderate to severe chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). When Dad died in 2010, our family knew nothing about CTE. Now, as a son, I own a stomach of guilt for not doing enough to help Mom or Dad in these final years.


Dad, #41, after the injury that ended his career; Courtesy of Lytle Family

Mom and Dad were a team for forty-years—from a first kiss near a pool table in her family’s basement to a final goodbye in a hospital room. She had earned her right to celebrate the accomplishments her husband achieved playing the sport that killed him.

Roger Goodell never played football after high school. He just made himself comfortable wearing a suit on NFL sidelines.

I watched Mom closely as the ceremony continued. Mom is a petite fighter with an inexhaustible will to serve others. Some have described her as a “saint” and most others claim she is the “kindest person in the world.” She taught elementary school for almost thirty years. Caring and compassion ruled her classroom. It was a place where young lives entered and left transformed for the better.

Throughout the Hall of Fame events, Mom had worn a practiced smile part genuine and part bittersweet. She had glowed earlier in the program, awed by the honor for her husband and cherishing the memories they had formed together. Now, I watched her eyes burn into the NFL Commissioner not more than two first downs from her. Goodell’s laughter had disrespected all former players and families who have had their lives altered by CTE.

Mom seethed and, as I learned later, debated whether to leave the ceremony. Her smile fled, but her composure remained. She sighed and forced back tears. Later, Mom remarked:

“I thought, if you (Goodell) only knew how Rob and so many others loved your game…and if you ever felt for one second their pain, you wouldn’t be smiling. You wouldn’t be laughing. And then, despite being furious, I felt sad. Not for your dad or myself. But sad over my disappointment in Goodell…that he doesn’t care…that he could never know just how much people like Rob and others love this sport…and sad for football itself. The game has a long way to go to fix its problems.”

Hall of Fame

Lytle Family (Mom in center flanked by Dad’s two sisters) at Hall of Fame



  1. Kelly, I was so proud of your mom to stay in her seat after that insensitive and ignorant remark was made. Showed one more example of support for Rob’s passion for the game.

    1. Yes. An example of great class in the face of a tasteless, smug action by someone who has proved it is only his interests that he serves.

  2. Excellent Kelly. Through out your Mom’s trial and tribulations,she continues to be one of the most loved and respected individuals I know.

  3. Excellent summary, Kelly. Your mom’s grace and decorum are inestimable. I would have had a hard time stopping myself from giving Goodall a concussion right then and there. Sitting on a bleacher next to your dad at Erin’s softball games when my daughter played was painful enough watching him readjust, get up and walk around, obviously more than suffering from “bleacher butt.” I feel guilty watching as much football as I do, but the siren song is so hard to resist, I can’t even imagine how seductive it was to a man of his talents.

  4. This truly is a sad commentary of just where the priorities of corporate NFL lie,
    But a great tribute to the two heroes and warriors, each in their own right,
    that you are privileged to call your parents.
    I hope your story of the struggles that your dad and mom both faced will reach more people that they too will see and understand the side of football that produces tears,
    And not cheers.

    1. Well said. What a beautiful closing. I do hope that more people understand and appreciate the “darker” side of sports and the human struggles of so many players – especially those who played before the multi-million dollar contracts of today.

  5. As I read this piece my heart broke. I love football and saddens me to feel the pain your mother must have felt her whole life. Now with that being said, it also breaks my heart knowing what “sevice and sacrific” means in a country that’s thinks nothing of paying players millions while our servicemen receive basically nothing. Good for you for being pissed, hurt, whatever your feeling may be and I’m sure everyone who reads your article will be as moved as I. But let us remember your father made the choice not the other way around.

    1. Thanks Alicia. And yes, Dad always said that all he ever wanted was “one more play. then maybe one more after that.” He loved football and chose the game despite the pain and suffering he would endure. He never held a grudge against the sport. And it is certainly a failing in this country that millions are paid to entertainers while those who have truly fought, suffered, and paid the ultimate sacrifice by serving in the armed forces on behalf of others are largely left to struggle on their own. This is an issue that hits close to home for our family as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s